A POVERTY OF REASON
Home ] About us ] Alphabetical archive ] Archeology ] Author submission screen ] Book reviews ] Canoeing ] correspondents ] date archive ] East Midlands ] Economics ] Education ] Environment ] Feminisim ] Fresh ] Geology ] Health ] hit counts ] House swaps ] Jokes ] iLinks ] Love ] Media ] Obituaries ] Paleontology ] Past thoughts ] Politics ] Poetry ] Quotes ] Religion ] Sex ] Site Awards ] Smartertimes past ] Spain ] Trade Unions ]

You have reached iGreens.org.uk.  In December 2006 we moved to iGreens.org with faster servers and discussion boards.  Click here to follow us.  

Home ] Up ]

Sustainable Development and Economic Growth by Wilfred Beckerman

Book review

The "sustainable development" movement has fostered such an expansion of bureaucratic activity that it now threatens liberty worldwide.

Adherents to the doctrine - which seeks to impose laws and restrictions to reduce economic growth to some unspecified "sustainable" level - employ pseudo-scientific claims and green-marketing hype to mask their hostility toward freedom and private-property rights, explains Oxford University economist Wilfred Beckerman in his new book, A POVERTY OF REASON.

"Support for sustainable development," Beckerman writes, "is based on a confusion about its ethical implications and on a flagrant disregard of the relevant factual evidence."

The sustainable-development movement claims that mankind will soon exhaust all of the Earth's natural resources and thus bring economic growth to a halt -- a claim Beckerman shows is false both on theoretical and empirical grounds. "The true prospects for economic growth over the course of this century are that future generations will be much richer than people alive today," according to Beckerman.

The movement also claims to represent the moral high ground because it places more emphasis on intergenerational equity than do conventional economic principles. However, after Beckerman's analysis it becomes clear that the campaign for sustainable development has no moral ground to stand on.

"The greatest contribution that we can make to the welfare of future generations," Beckerman argues, "is to bequeath a free and democratic society. And the best means of bequeathing such a society to future generations is to improve respect for human rights and democratic values today.

"Because these rights are currently violated in most countries of the world, bequeathing a more decent and just society to future generations in no way conflicts with the interests of people alive today. There is no conflict between generations, therefore, with respect to the most important contribution that can be made to human welfare, and hence no trade-off is necessary between the interests of the present generation and the interests of future generations."

In short, Beckerman shows that the campaign for sustainable-development policies suffers from a poverty of reason.

To order A POVERTY OF REASON: Sustainable Development and Economic Growth, by Wilfred Beckerman, click here 

 

 

Home ] Up ]

You have reached iGreens.org.uk.  In December 2006 we moved to iGreens.org with faster servers and discussion boards.  Click here to follow us.  

Send mail to enquiries@igreens.org.uk  with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: November 12, 2006