Do the Al Quaeda terrorists deserve this?
Home ] Barbara Castle's principles ] Big girls don't cry ] Clare Short is an iGreen ] Conservative radicalism ] Drugs ] Elections ] Europe ] International Affairs ] 9/11 stuff ] Little platoons ] Margaret Thatcher quotes ] Oppose the Data Protection Act ] Pim Fortuyn ] Politician watch ] Public and private discrimination ] Tam Dalyell is a racist ] War ]

You have reached iGreens.org.uk.  In December 2006 we moved to iGreens.org with faster servers and discussion boards.  Click here to follow us.  

Home ] Up ]

Most Americans seem to take a pretty robust attitude to the treatment of the alleged Al Quaeda terrorists currently held in Cuba and, like Donald Rumsfeld, probably lose little sleep over their situation.  Understandably so, given the terrible events of September 11, and the danger that Al Quaeda plan more.  Americans also find European questioning of their treatment as at best puzzling, and probably attribute it to the knee-jerk anti-Americanism of so many misguided people on this side of the Atlantic.   This is why America’s real friends, and iGreens regard themselves as just that, must speak out. 

We don’t yet know all the details.   If treating the Al Quaeda as prisoners of war under the Geneva convention prohibits interrogation to prevent further acts of mass murder, then the Geneva convention is an ass and you are right to ignore it.   If treating them as as ordinary criminals would have delayed extraditing them to secure prisons, and risked further atrocities, then again the law is an ass and you were right to remove them from Afghanistan by force.  Trying them in military courts may be the best and safest option.  Those who are found guilty of planning mass murder deserve to die, and to minimise retaliation, any executions should be carried out swiftly.

However, America is defending civilisation in this war.  In civilised countries people are innocent until proven guilty in a proper court.   The Red Cross and other human rights organisations should be allowed to see how they are being treated, and America should have to defend its actions in the court of world opinion.  Don't worry about the loony left.  They will always whinge.  Reasonable people understand if you have to break a few rules, so long as you explain what you're doing and why.  You’ve won the first phase of the war, so you don’t need to be gratuitously vindictive.  Be firm and just and show the rest of the world why freedom, democracy, and capitalism are worth defending.

Jim Thornton 19 Jan 2002

 

Update 24 August 2002

Some readers have misread the above as a veiled attack on America.   Nothing could be further from the truth.  Read iGreens response to 9/11 here.  

 

 

Home ] Up ]

You have reached iGreens.org.uk.  In December 2006 we moved to iGreens.org with faster servers and discussion boards.  Click here to follow us.  

Send mail to enquiries@igreens.org.uk  with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: February 05, 2006